NewsArun-3 Hydro Project: Developer claims compensation citing ‘change in law’
Kathmandu, Feb 13: The Indian developer of the Arun-3 Hydropower Project has claimed compensation from the government for failing to abide by its commitment to give continuity to the laws that existed when the project development agreement (PDA) was signed.
SJVN Arun-3 Power Development Company (SAPDC), the developer of the 900 MW project, has demanded compensation under the ‘change in law’ provision in the PDA after the government failed to provide forest land required to develop the scheme.
The project needs to lease 125 hectares of forest land to build an access road and implement the civil works of the hydropower project.
As per the laws prevailing at the time the PDA was signed, the project developer has to pay lease fees to the government and plant double the number of trees that are cut down at the leased land.
After the Forest Ministry asked the SAPDC to buy an equivalent amount of land and create a forest on it, the developer refused. The ministry’s demand is based on an upcoming guideline governing the acquisition of forest land for infrastructure development.
Instead of complying with the ministry’s demand, SAPDC dispatched a letter to the Investment Board Nepal (IBN) seeking compensation invoking the ‘change in law’ clause in the PDA.
“Our company believes that the government has introduced a new law which is totally different from what was prevailing while signing the PDA,” said Hari Ram Subedi, resident representative of SAPDC. “So, our company has the right mandated by the PDA to seek compensation from the government.”
The IBN has acknowledged receiving the letter from the project developer asking for compensation, but refused to make any official comments on it. “We have received such a letter from the developer, and the board will issue a statement to the media only after consultation with its lawyers,” said Madhu Prasad Bhetuwal, joint secretary at the IBN.
According to reliable sources at the IBN, the board will first try to resolve the dispute with the developer through consultation and discussion. However, if the dispute is not resolved, the developer might go to the Singapore International Arbitration Centre to resolve it through arbitration.
Since the argument put forward by the developer is well backed by the PDA, they have a very strong case, and the Nepal government might have to pay a hefty sum in compensation as well as the arbitration fee.
“It would be in the best interest of everyone if the Forest Ministry postpones the introduction of the new guideline and allows the developer to acquire the forest land under the old law,” said the source.
“Otherwise, the ministry should simplify the land acquisition process as directed by a joint meeting of the parliamentary Agriculture and Water Resources and Development committees on April 3, 2016.”
They had instructed the Forest Ministry to put in place a legal provision within a month under which infrastructure projects can acquire forest land by paying a certain fee. According to the directive, the amount, which will be determined by the ministry, will be used to develop a new forest equivalent in size to the deforested area.
However, the ministry ignored the joint directive issued by the House panels and is planning to introduce a guideline based on the directive issued by the Natural Resources Committee under the previous Parliament. It directs the government to put in place a legal provision barring forest land from being used for other purposes. If forest land has to be used for any other purpose, the acquirer must return an equivalent forest area to the government.
Source: The Kathmandu Postcomments powered by Disqus
Interview+ View All
We should aim to consume power domestically rather than export it
Energy Minister Janardan Sharma has been the talk of town lately because of his initiation to reform the Nepal Electricity Authority (NEA) and free the Capital from load shedding, while minimising power outages throughout the country.
Demand of electricity will definitely rise if we are able to supply more: Kulman Ghising
The government recently appointed Kulman Ghising as the Managing Director of Nepal Electricity Authority — the country’s sole power off-taker. Ghising has been associated with NEA for over...
Article+ View All
स्वच्छ ऊर्जाको फोहोरी रहस्य
सौर्य ऊर्जा उत्पादनमा प्रयोग गरिने प्रविधि फोटोभोल्टाइक सेल र वायु ऊर्जा उत्पादन गर्न प्रयोग गरिने टर्बाइन आविष्कार भएको करिब १ सय ५० वर्षपछि पनि विश्वको कुल ऊर्जा उत्पादनको झन्डै ७ प्रतिशत मात्र विद्युत् नवीकरणीय ऊर्जा प्रविधिबाट उत्पादन भएको पाइन्छ ।
How Nepal got the electricity flowing
For years, Hemkumari Chaulagain dreamed of getting a good night’s sleep. She didn’t mind rising early to receive predawn deliveries at her small shop in Kathmandu, Nepal. What wore her down was powering up the water pump each night to ensure the water storage tank atop her home stayed filled.
मलाई काठमाडौंमा लोडसेडिङ अन्त्य गर्छु भन्ने थियो । तर यतिसम्म गर्न सकिन्छ भन्ने विश्वास थिएन । तर अहिले यतिसम्म काम गर्न सकिँदो रहेछ भन्ने अनुभव भएको छ । काठमाडौं, पोखराको मात्र लोडसेडिङ अन्त्य गरेर हामीलाई सुख थिएन । हामीले तराईतिर लोडसेडिङ न्यूनीकरण गर्न नसकेको भए सबैभन्दा ठूलो चिन्ताको विषय त्यही हुन्थ्यो । त्यहाँ व्यापक विरोध आउने सम्भावना थियो ।
वातावरणीय सेवाको भुक्तानी कार्यान्वयनका लागि सम्झौता
जलविद्युत् आयोजनामा थेग्रिने समस्यालाई न्यून गर्न वातावरणीय सेवाको भुक्तानी कार्यक्रमको प्रभावकारी कार्यन्वयन गर्न एक सम्झौतापत्रमा आज हस्ताक्षर भएको छ । मस्र्याङ्दी जलाधार क्षेत्रका जलविद्युत् प्रर्वद्धकहरुको सञ्जाल र मस्र्याङ्दी वातावरणीय सेवा व्यवस्थापन सञ्जालले कार्यक्रम कार्यान्वयनका लागि उक्त सम्झौता...
पूर्व-पश्चिम रेलमार्गका लागि रूख काट्न अनुमति
सरकारले पूर्वपश्चिम रेलमार्गअन्तर्गत बर्दिबासदेखि सिमरासम्मको २५ किलोमिटर खण्ड निर्माणको बाटो खुला गरेको छ । सरकारले यो खण्डमा पर्ने सागरनाथ वन विकास परियोजनाका ११ हजार एक सय २३ वटा रूख काट्न अनुमति दिएको छ ।