ArticleFumbling in the dark
The renewable energy sector is suffering due to rifts between the AEPC and donors
The Alternative Energy Promotion Centre (AEPC), Nepal’s apex government body for the promotion of renewable energy, turned 20 this month. How the AEPC managed to provide improved cooking and lighting solutions 3.6 million households in a span of two decades is something that should earn it praise and applause. However, unbeknownst to many, the institution is also riddled with rifts and complications. Lately, there has been a serious split with a few of its donors. This break-up is not devoid of drama, lies, distrust and conspiracies. If the issue is not resolved quickly, severe damage will be caused to this new industry in Nepal that was instituted by decades of service and hard work of many professionals, renewable energy advocates, private sector organisations, civil society organisations, multiple well-wishers and development partners.
In June last year, the Ministry of Finance received an angry letter from the Embassy of Denmark saying that it was freezing its funding to the National Rural and Renewable Energy Programme (NRREP)—a $170-million renewable energy undertaking—citing lack of progress on the AEPC’s part to do something about the formation of cartels by solar companies. A number of private firms had formed a cartel and were forcing consumers to buy high-priced large systems. This problem cannot be fixed by enforcing compliance control or imposing penalties. It needs systemic intervention. The AEPC and the donors should have reflected upon their own modus operandi and fixed it first. However, the easiest option the donors chose was to freeze their funding and wait to see how the AEPC would deal with the problem.
This action that brought the whole sector to a screeching halt has left many baffled. While I don’t question the donors’ intention to clear the mess before it spread further, I am equally of the opinion that it was one of their most irresponsible and unethical decisions to distance themselves from a problem that they partly helped create. It would be wrong to place all the blame on the AEPC. As the donors started imposing a series of audits and compliance orders, things became more complex as it started unearthing other lapses one after another. This created a huge burden on the weak AEPC bureaucracy which is already hindered by political meddling and internal rifts.
All the field work and installations came to a complete halt as the AEPC attempted to respond to the donors’ requirements. The AEPC couldn’t even spend the resources provided by the state and lenient donors. And something else not seen in the renewable energy sector ever before started unfolding. Some donors took micro meddling too far under the veil of advisor assistance and began interfering in the state’s affairs in the name of making their aid more effective. This led to a new division of opinion among the donors themselves. The harsh truth is that a whole year was spent on negotiations with not a single technology installed, making it the darkest year in the history of renewables in Nepal.
How ethical is it for the donors to take
credit for the successes of the past and blame the AEPC for the mess for which they are partly responsible? What is equally strange is the profound lack of empathy as shown by their blocking of all services when the whole country had been traumatised by the killer quake and the Indian blockade, and all that the people wanted was basic energy solutions.
This issue of unethical dealing in solar installations not only became a dominant issue in the sector, it later also served as a major reference for the revision of Subsidy Policy 2016. It is probably one of the costliest policy revision exercises ever held in Nepal considering the fact that it was prepared at the cost of blocking all renewable
energy services for an entire year. However, the fate of this policy is still unknown as the debate does not look like ending
anytime soon. This is not a past issue that I am talking about. Compliance negotiations are still going on between the AEPC, donors and private sector with no realisation of what they are getting themselves into. No surprise that the AEPC today outsources more accountants and auditors than technicians and engineers.
The fact is that there seems to be serious problems at both ends of the spectrum. The broader problem is that the donors have been constantly denying their role in bringing the institution to this mess and want the AEPC alone to take the responsibility. Donors, I hope you are listening. We know that the Nepali bureaucracy has serious lapses, corruption is flourishing and unethical dealings by private companies are rampant. And, like you, we too do not want our taxpayer money to be misused by greedy bureaucrats or pocketed by any unethical private firm. But, in the name of controls and compliances, your requirements should not become another burden on the weak bureaucracy instead of helping it to reform.
We agree that there seems to be a gross problem in the AEPC’s ability to handle these new challenges and the complexity of the issue of subsidy misappropriation, but in the name of good governance and aid effectiveness, donor micro meddling and high-handedness without accepting their own role in creating the mess is equally dangerous. It does not earn them a good
reputation either. This current myopia of believing that short-term compliance orders can solve the problem without understanding the systemic lapses in the design and structure of the NRREP will merely be a zero-sum blame game. This toxic conflict which threatens to paralyse the growth of the entire sector should not be prolonged. Donors, I hope you are listening.
- Kandel is an energy policy expert
Source: Ekantipurcomments powered by Disqus
Interview+ View All
लगानीको प्रतिबद्धता आएमा लाइसेन्स तत्काल पाउने व्यवस्था हुनुपर्छ: ज्ञानेन्द्रलाल प्रधान
अहिले पनि आयोजनामा हिंसात्मक गतिविधि भएका छन् । लगानी भए पनि लाइसेन्स पाउने अवस्था छैन । लगानीको प्रतिबद्धता आएमा लाइसेन्स तत्काल पाउने व्यवस्था हुनुपर्छ । स्थानीयको अवरोध छ । नेपाल विद्युत् प्राधिकरणले पीपीए दिन ६ महीना लगाउँछ । अनलाइन एप्लिकेशन दिएपछि आफै पीपीए हुने...
‘तामाकोसी–३ एनआरएनकै लगानीमा निर्माण गर्न प्रयास गर्छु’: भवन भट्ट
पूर्वाधार विकास, पर्यटन तथा वित्तीय क्षेत्रमा बढी जोड दिएको छु । काठमाडौं–हेटौंडा सुरुङमार्गमा मेरो संलग्नता छ । यसलाई निर्माण चरणमा पुर्याउनु छ । वित्तीय स्रोत जुट्न नसक्दा यो आयोजना अघि बढ्न सकेको छैन ।
मलाई काम गर्न दिने हो भने अहिलेको मूल्यलाई अझ घटाएरप्राधिकरणलाई नाफा हुने वातावरण बनाउन सक्छु: उर्जा मन्त्रि
यदि मलाई साँच्चिकै काम गर्न दिने हो भने र मेरो गतिलाई पछ्याउने हो भने अहिलेको मूल्यलाई अझ घटाएर विद्युत् प्राधिकरणलाई नाफा हुने वातावरण बनाउन सक्छु । यो प्रकारको कार्ययोजना मसँग छ । सबैभन्दा पहिलो त विद्युत् प्राधिकरणको आम्दानीको १/१ रुपैयाँको हिसाबकिताब हुनुपर्छ ।
Article+ View All
Prospects of Low Head Hydro Power System in Karnali Region of Nepal
The Government of Nepal has a new federal government after promulgation of new constitution and new government also set a target to end the crisis in Nepal in period of their governance .
पञ्चेश्वर बहुउद्देश्यीय आयोजनाको विवाद कायमै; कार्य प्रगति कागजमै सिमित
भारतीय प्रधानमन्त्री नरेन्द्र मोदीले बोलेझैँ भएको भए आज पञ्चेश्वर बहुउद्देश्यीय आयोजनाको निर्माण करिब २५ प्रतिशत पूरा हुन्थ्यो । तर, अझै पनि आयोजना निर्माण हुने कि नहुने भन्ने अन्योल छ । भारतले महाकाली सन्धिअनुसार नेपाललाई दिनुपर्ने पानीको परिमाणमा किचलो गर्दा काम सुरु भएको ४ वर्षसम्म पनि डिपिआर पूरा भएको छैन । पानीका विषयमा २२ वर्षअघि सन्धि हुँदा जे विवाद थियो, अहिले पनि त्यही छ ।
What a Wind Energy
Wind energy is freely available source of energy. However, the main issue in wind is that its availability mainly depends on the metrological conditions. The power output from wind farms is determined by the prevailing wind speed and direction and cannot be adjusted as conveniently as the power production from the conventional power plants...
दक्षिण एशियाकै पहिलो वातावरणमैत्री भवन नेपालमा
जल तथा मौसम विज्ञान विभागले दक्षिण एशियाकै पहिलो वातावरणमैत्री भवन निर्माण गरिरहेको छ । विभागको बबरमहलस्थित निर्माणाधीन भवन बनेपछि वातावरण प्रणालीका हिसाबले दक्षिण एशियाकै पहिलो हुने विभागका महानिर्देशक डा ऋषिराज शर्माले जानकारी दिनुभयो ।
निकम्मा बनाइँदैछ रेल विभाग
नेपालमा सार्वजनिक यातायातको रुपमा रेल सेवालाई व्यवस्थित गर्न स्थापना गरिएको रेल विभाग जनशक्तिको अभावमा निकम्माजस्तै बनाइएको छ । विभागमा आवश्यक मात्रामा जनशक्ति र रेलसम्बन्धी इञ्जिनियरसमेत नहुँदा विभागले राम्रोसँग काम गर्न सकेको छैन । एक वर्षअघि नै सम्पन्न भइसक्नुपर्ने....
नेप्से परिसूचक ११ दशमलव शून्य ५ अङ्कले गिरावट
साताको पहिलो दिन नेप्से परिसूचक शून्य दशमलव ७८ प्रतिशत घटेर बन्द भएको छ । यस दिन ११ दशमलव शून्य ५ अङ्क घटेर १ हजार ४ सय १३ दशमलव ९० विन्दुमा पुगेको छ । कारोबार शुरु भएको १५ मिनेटमा १७ अङ्क बढेर १ हजार ४ सय ४४ दशमलव ८५ विन्दुमा पुगेको बजार अन्त्यसम्म सो विन्दुमा टिक्न...